Cardio-protective effect of Saturated Fats – Hormonal Obesity XXXIX

/, Food, Health and Nutrition, Hormonal Obesity, IDM, Insulin/Cardio-protective effect of Saturated Fats – Hormonal Obesity XXXIX

Saturated fats turned out to be not quite as toxic as we had believed once the trans fats were stripped out.  But many studies pointed out the fact that there is a chance that they may actually be protective against heart disease.  The study “Dietary fats, carbohydrate, and progression of coronary atherosclerosis in postmenopausal women” examined the angiographic progression of coronary disease in relationship to diets.CAD and fats

An angiogram is a standard heart test where dye is put into the arteries around the heart to determine if there are any blockages.  Looking at 235 women with established heart disease, they measured baseline angiograms and repeated them in an average of 3.1 years.  They then looked at the diets of these women to see if there were any patterns.

Dividing these women into groups according to their intake of fats, there appears to be no relationship whatsoever.  The women eating the most fat had slightly less blockages than those eating the least.

The one macronutrient that stands out as particularly sinister is carbohydrates.  The highest intake of carbohydrates is associated with the highest level of heart blockages.  Not looking too good for the Diet-Heart hypothesis.  The people who were eating the American Heart Association approved low fat diet were getting the heart disease.  The people eating the frowned-upon high fat diets were not.CAD and fat2

The types of dietary fat were further divided to see if the all natural saturated fats were indeed dangerous to human health.  The group eating the most saturated fat had regression of their blockages.  Their heart disease was melting away!  On the other hand, the group eating the least saturated fats had the most progression of their disease.

Looking at the industrial vegetable oils, it appears that eating more of these oils tended to be associated with more progression.  Wait a friggin second.  Weren’t these vegetable oils supposed to be ‘heart-healthy’?  Wasn’t the saturated fats supposed to be clogging arteries?  It looks like the effect is the exact opposite of what we were taught.  This wasn’t just some rinky dink study either.  It was written by Dr. Mozaffarian from a little school known as Harvard.  Saturated fats weren’t bad, they were good for health.Malmo sat fat

Another large study “Dietary fat intake and early mortality patterns – data from The Malmo Diet and Cancer Study” followed over 29,000 subjects over 6.6 years.  Among the women, increasing saturated fat intake was associated with a significantly lower risk of dying of heart disease.  Again, not looking too good for the Diet-Heart Hypothesis.  Eating saturated fat doesn’t really appear to be harmful in any way.

The same results were seen in the study ”Dietary intake of saturated fatty acids and mortality from cardiovascular disease in Japanese“.  Following a cohort of 58,543 Japanese men and women over 14.1 years, the researchers looked at the the relationship between heart disease, stroke and saturated fat intake.  Not surprisingly, there was an inverse relationship.  That means that eating more saturated fat protects against heart disease and stroke.  In 2014, the Japan Collaborative Cohort Study found virtually identical results.  From their conclusions, “total mortality was inversely associated with intakes of saturated fatty acids (SFA)”.  Yes, saturated fat is not bad for you, it’s good for you.Sat fat japan

Several large scale and highly publicized meta-analyses have been done on all trials to date regarding saturated fat.  In 2009, Dr Krause published, “Meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies evaluating the association of saturated fat with cardiovascular disease“.  After careful analysis of 21 studies covering 347,747 patients, he concluded:

there is no significant evidence for concluding that dietary saturated fat is associated with an increased risk of CHD

Furthermore, there was a small but significant protective effect on stroke.

Dr. Chowdhury in his paper  “Association of Dietary, Circulating, and Supplement Fatty Acids With Coronary Risk: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis” came to much the same conclusions.  While trans fat increased the risk of coronary disease, saturated fat did not.  There was no concern that polyunsaturated fats were causing disease.  Yet.

Polyunsaturated fats contain both omega 3s and omega 6s.  While both are found in nature, our current diet may be heavily and unhealthily skewed toward omega 6s.  Dr. Ramsden decided to analyze all the studies to date regarding polyunsaturated fats, but divided the fat and published the paper, “Use of dietary linoleic acid for secondary prevention of coronary heart disease and death“. omega6 and death

The overall picture showed no increase risk of death with polyunsaturated fat.  However, upon closer inspection, you can see that those trials that increased omega 3 consumption showed protection against heart disease.  Those studies that increased omega 6 consumption increased heart disease.  The omega 6, if you remember is primarily the vegetable oils that we consume far in excess of the omega 3 by a factor of 15 to 30.

Awwww.  Snap.  Nutritionism strikes again.  All polyunsaturates are not the same.  We are belatedly recognizing the fact that highly inflammatory, processed vegetable oils may not be ‘heart healthy’ after all.  More likely they are ‘heart harmful’.  And margarine just changed from trans fats to vegetable oils…..  The advice to change from saturated fat to vegetable oil may not have been good.Minn Coron Survery

The only long term randomized trial “Test of Effect of Lipid Lowering by Diet on Cardiovascular Risk” by Dr. Frantz, looked at the effect of switching had shown this decades earlier.  The Minnesota Coronary Survey randomized 9,057 inmates at a psychiatric facility to follow a standard diet with 39% fat (18% saturated, 5% polyunsaturated, 16% monounsaturated, 446 mg cholesterol) to a 38% fat diet much lower in saturated fats (9% saturated, 15% polyunsaturated, 14% monounsaturated, 166 mg cholesterol).  This was achieved by changing to egg substitute, margarine and low fat beef – all delicious, artificial foods.  Over a follow up period of 4.5 years, they could not demonstrate any benefit in terms of heart disease.

However, they were able to demonstrate a difference in total mortality.  It was just not the one they were looking for.  The treatment group was dying at a faster rate than the control group eating all the saturated fat.  What?  Eating artificial, man-made, industrially processed substitute food is not good for you?  How can that possibly be?

Continue to A Closer Look at Cortisol – Hormonal Obesity XXXX

Start here with Calories I – How Do We Gain Weight?

See the entire lecture – The Aetiology of Obesity 6/6 – Fat Phobia

2017-09-02T11:54:15+00:00 0 Comments

About the Author:

Dr. Fung is a Toronto based kidney specialist, having graduated from the University of Toronto and finishing his medical specialty at the University of California, Los Angeles in 2001. He is the author of the bestsellers ‘The Obesity Code’ and ‘The Complete Guide to Fasting’. He has pioneered the use of therapeutic fasting for weight loss and type 2 diabetes reversal in his IDM clinic.

Leave a Reply

18 Comments on "Cardio-protective effect of Saturated Fats – Hormonal Obesity XXXIX"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Tony
Guest

Do you know of any animal studies looking at the effects of high saturated fat (trans fats removed) diet vs low saturated fat diet. Might be a great thesis project.

terry
Guest

So Dean Ornish, Caldwell esselstyn, John Mcdougall etc. are all wrong???????????
COM’ON GET REAL

kfacwpup
Admin
Why do you think they are correct? You may, of course choose to believe whatever you wish. You choose to believe Dr. Ornish but not Dr. Atkins. You believe Dr. Mcdougall, but not Dr. Peter Attia, or Dr. William Davis or Dr. Roland Krauss. You believe Dr Esselstyn, but not Dr. Oz, who has recently changed his mind on saturated fats. My own opinion is that the saturated fats that humans have been consuming for thousands of years is not intrinsically harmful to the heart. Drs. Atkins, Davis, Krauss and Oz are all cardiologists, by the way.
bachcole
Guest

I believe what we have adapted to for hundreds of millions of years and the traditional cuisines that have been prepared for us for thousands of years up to the industrial revolution.

Mike PhD
Guest

May I call you Jason? Really you are a hero. You cast aside years of “training” and embraced the data. You even admitted your errors.

As the great ethologist Konrad Lorenz once said,
“it keeps one young to discard a favored theory before breakfast”.

Kevin
Guest

So the during these periods of fasting (24h 36h etc) is the body going into periodic ketosis state. Is this what the IDM program is about and trying to achieve ?

bachcole
Guest

I am not Jason Fung, but I have read every post up to this one, and their program is more than just ketosis. There is also autophagy and many other benefits of fasting, intermittent or otherwise, plus dietary recommendations.

Martin
Guest
Hello Jason, I am familiar with the argument you have presented that saturated fat might not be as harmful for the heart as previously thought and indeed may even be a healthy form of fat in this respect, however, I have also recently been made aware of a possible connection between saturated fat and insulin resistance; since diabetes is caused by insulin resistance, does not the possible connection between saturated fat and this condition cause you to have doubts about recommending increased consumption? By the way, I have only recently discovered your message concerning treating diabetes via seeking to reduce… Read more »
trackback

[…] Continue to Cardio-Protective Effect of Saturated Fat – Hormonal Obesity XXXIX […]

neeta
Guest
The post menopausal studies you quote bring something far more important than just “dietary saturated fat improves cardio outlook”. You have to look beyond the fat and realize that cholesterol is the precursor to the hormonal cascade. Without it we women can’t make the hormones we desparate need after menopause. You can’t make pregnenolone progesterone dhea etc on low fat high carb diets. Once I went on hormone replacement my sugars balanced.Progesterone was required. Without it my cortisol goes through the roof. Eating more like my grandparents did is what has brought me back to health. Whole foods grass pastured… Read more »
Tim
Guest
Martin: If what you mean is that high levels of plasma saturated fat are associated with higher insulin levels and insulin resistance then I think you are correct as this makes eminent sense. The question becomes where does the plasma sat-fat originate? Its been established by Volek and Phinney among others, that high fat diets, including high sat-fat reduce circulating plasma fat, they do not increase it. However carb intake above your carb tolerance (approx 50g/day for most people) results in sat-fat production in the liver via de novo VLDL synthesis which obviously increases plasma sat-fat. So its very possible… Read more »
A Pedantic Reader
Guest

“Awwww. Snap.” I hate this kind of stuff in your writing, am I watching MTV or reading about medical studies?

A millennial, of course.
Guest
A millennial, of course.

I actually found that extremely charming. It made me chuckle out loud and want to read more.
Pedantic indeed. 😉

bachcole
Guest

I love his sense of humor.

bachcole
Guest

Oh, I forgot to mention that I am almost 71 years old and pretty conservative, but I still love his sense of humor.

trackback

[…] rasvakaan kohtuullisesti käytettynä ei ole SVT:n syy. Tässä J.Fungin tulkinta v. 2004 julkaistusta tutkimuksesta (koskee postmenopausaalisia […]

darshan prasad
Guest

So true with the carbs.. since a month I reduced my carb and took two 36 hours fast during the period. Did not reduce proteins or fats and for cholesterol I had 4 whole eggs. All my lipid value improved. Triglycerides dropped from 132 to 71. Vldl from 37 to 24. Hdl from 46.8 to 58.7. Except ldl which increased by 11 units. But I guess the friedewalds equation skewed it up since triglycerides value is below 100. The enemy here is refined carbs and eating based on specific timing rather than the call of hunger.

Blinglingy
Guest

Hi Dr Fung, I know you don’t recommend artificial sweeteners. How abt Stevia? Is it acceptable?

Have you heard of Oat Fiber? It has 0 carbs and mostly Fiber. Is it ok to use oat Fiber to make carb free food?

wpDiscuz